The knives are out once again. The third installment in Rian Johnson’s acclaimed whodunit series, Wake Up Dead Man: A Knives Out Mystery, has dropped its first poster, confirming a December 12 Netflix release following a limited theatrical run beginning November 26. The film, once again led by Daniel Craig as detective Benoit Blanc, promises to take the franchise into uncharted thematic territory with what Johnson describes as Blanc’s “most personal journey yet.”
Set in a quiet hamlet in upstate New York, the mystery begins when an impossible murder rattles a close-knit community led by charismatic Monsignor Jefferson Wicks (Josh Brolin) and his young assistant priest Jud Duplenticy (Josh O’Connor). The congregation includes an ensemble of familiar Hollywood names: Glenn Close, Thomas Haden Church, Kerry Washington, Daryl McCormack, Jeremy Renner, Andrew Scott, and Cailee Spaeny. After the shocking crime, local police chief Geraldine Scott (Mila Kunis) calls on Blanc, whose insistence that “This was dressed as a miracle, it’s just a murder. And I solve murders” underlines the film’s tension between faith and reason.
Johnson, who earned Oscar nominations for both Knives Out and Glass Onion, sees fertile ground in this church-set story. “Themes of guilt, mystery, morality, and fallible humanity all feel right at home in a church, with a man of God in the center of the mix,” he says. “I have strong feelings about faith: both my own personal experience and how it intersects with our country’s cultural and civic life, and the ways that intersection touches all of us differently. So it felt like rich ground for a good story.”
While the ultra-contemporary Glass Onion skewered tech moguls and the cult of excess, Johnson frames Wake Up Dead Man as a gothic return to the genre’s roots. “It’s more similar to the first Knives Out in that it gets back to the real origins of the genre, which predate Agatha Christie, going back to Edgar Allan Poe,” he explains. Production designer Rick Heinrichs built the cavernous stone chapel that serves as the mystery’s stage, and cinematographer Steve Yedlin deepens the atmosphere with stark chiaroscuro lighting. “It’s still a Benoit Blanc mystery, so it’s funny and fun,” Johnson says, “but it’s set in an old stone church, there are lots of graveyards.”
Craig, reprising Blanc for the third time, praises Johnson’s balance of tradition and innovation. “What Rian’s movies do best,” Craig says, “is subvert the genre. You start off thinking you’re watching an old-fashioned sort of Agatha Christie-type mystery — but then it shifts, and you realize you’re watching something entirely different.”
The director also hints at shifting narrative focus, emphasizing that Blanc is never the sole center of these films. “The secret to each one of these movies is that Benoit Blanc is not the main character of these films. There’s always a protagonist who has some real stakes and skin in the game,” Johnson says. “Josh’s character Jud is that character in this movie.” For O’Connor, who navigates Jud’s crisis of faith, working with Johnson was revelatory: “He’s a sensational filmmaker. What’s surprising to me always is when a brilliant director is also a brilliant writer, because to me, they’re very different skill sets. Rian has both, and he’s very funny, very smart, deeply kind, and patient. It’s really rare what he has.”
The ensemble itself reflects Johnson’s growing pull in Hollywood. “Every single day on set with this ensemble, I would blink and be astounded that we talked these people into showing up,” Johnson admits. “The experience of making these movies and the chemistry between these incredible actors is the key to why we love doing them. You get great actors together, you let them hang out, and games will ensue.”
Wake Up Dead Man will premiere at the Toronto International Film Festival on September 6 before opening the BFI London Film Festival on October 8. Its staggered rollout — first in select theaters, then worldwide on Netflix — mirrors the path of Glass Onion, positioning the film for both awards-season buzz and mass streaming appeal. Whether this latest mystery continues Johnson’s streak of critical and commercial success will be revealed soon, but one thing is certain: Benoit Blanc is far from done unraveling impossible murders.
Benoit Blanc’s latest mystery has its world premiere this week — but we want to hear from you. Share your theories with us on X/Twitter and Instagram, and head to CelebMix for more movie stories like this one.